This beautiful, brand new lake front home features 180′ of lake front property, with a floor plan that focuses on indoor/outdoor living and features stunning lake views from all rooms. With 3 bedrooms and a bunk room, it accommodates 13 comfortably. In addition, the rental includes use of a community tennis court.

The McCarthy Cottage got its name because our Granny McCarthy bought the property and built our camp in 1949. Five generations have run up and down those stairs to the lake, played kick-the-can on the lawn, and learned to play tennis on the clay courts. With the original property showing its wear, we made the decision in 2020 to completely rebuild the house. While the building is fully new, it still has its original charm (and some of the original knotty cedar/pine!) and is sure to preserve the memories for generations to come.

We’ve now been renting the house for one year, and we are amazed at the variety of renters who find rest, beauty, and fun at this house. From giant family reunions, to sophisticated foodie retreats, to destination Christmases, to honeymoons – there’s something for everyone here, and everyone says they feel right at home. That was our goal- keep the homeyness and simplicity of our original camp with the added comfort of all things clean, soft, quiet, and AIR-CONDITIONED elements!

Contact us to book the McCarthy Cottage!

A quote from one of our renters

We felt very lucky to have the opportunity to rent such a beautiful home. The home itself is impeccable as well as all of the high end appliances and furniture. Beautiful views, nice lake access, friendly neighbors met during fun walks along the private road, and a perfect porch. The host, Betsy, and her family welcomed us warmly and made it possible for our family to have a very lovely time in their special cottage.

---

House Details

Per Night Rate*

• $650 per night from Nov-April
• $750 per night for May & Oct
• $1000 per night from June – September
• Additional $250 house cleaning fee per stay

*Minimum 3-night stay year-round

Rooms

• Bedroom 1: King
• Bedroom 2: Queen
• Bedroom 3: Queen
• Bedroom 4: 2 queens, 3 singles (2 are bunk beds)

Amenities

• Air Conditioning & Heat
• High-Speed Wifi
• Generator
• Full kitchen (incl coffee maker, pots/pans, spices, oils…etc)
• Grill
• Washer/Dryer
• Smart TV
• Screens on all doors/windows
• Two adult kayaks & two kid-sized kayaks
• Two stand-up paddle boards
• Use of community tennis courts
• Non-smoking

Cancellation policy:

Damages & Incidentals: You will be responsible for any damage to the rental property caused by you or your party during your stay.

Check in after: 3:00 PM Check out before: 11:00 AM

---

Things to do in Skaneateles

Food

• Gilda’s pizza; good for vegan & vegetarian options or a light dinner; located in the village
• Good Eats healthy bowls; good for vegan & vegetarian options and takeout; located in the village
• Blue Water Grill fun family friendly; reasonably priced fish restaurant located in the village on the lake
• The Krebs newly renovated Skaneateles landmark in the village; American fare; expensive and not a good family option
• Doug’s Fish Fry classic fried fish restaurant; casual and great for families; a Central NY favorite; located in the village
• Sherwood Inn restaurant and bar located in one of the historic Skaneateles landmarks; good for families; reasonably priced
• Elderberry Pond farm-to-table restaurant; outside of Skaneateles, so a bit of a drive; beautiful food and setting; on the expensive side
• Elephant and the Dove new Mexican restaurant in the village; good for gluten free and vegetarian options
• Joelle’s French bistro; limited menu of fine dining; located about 3miles outside of the village; only open Thurs/Fri/Sat
• Moro’s Kitchen an extensive menu of Italian (plus other cuisines); great for families and reasonably priced; good for gluten free; located in the village
• Skaneateles Bakery best little spot in town for breakfast and lunch and don’t miss the cookies to go!
• Patisserie adorable bakery in town; their stretch bread cannot be missed!

Recreation

• x
• y
• z